India’s direct tax collection to fall for the first time in two decades: sources


India’s corporate and income tax collection for the current year is likely to fall for the first time in at least two decades, several senior tax officials told Reuters, amid a sharp fall in economic growth and cut in corporate tax rates.


Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government was targeting direct tax collection of 13.5 trillion rupees ($189 billion) for the year ending March 31 – a 17% increase over the prior fiscal year.


But a sharp decline in demand has stung businesses, forcing companies to cut investment and jobs, denting tax collections and prompting the government to forecast 5% growth for this fiscal year – the slowest in 11 years.


The tax department had managed to collect only 7.3 trillion rupees as of Jan. 23, more than 5.5% below the amount collected by the same point last year, said a senior tax official.


After collecting taxes from companies in advance for the first three quarters, officials typically garner about 30-35% of annual direct taxes in the final three months, data from the past three years shows.


But eight senior tax officials interviewed by Reuters said despite their best efforts, direct tax collections this financial year were likely to fall below the 11.5 trillion collected in 2018-19.


“Forget the target. This will be the first time that we’ll see a fall in direct tax collection ever,” said a tax official in New Delhi.


He estimates that direct tax collections for this year could end up roughly 10% below fiscal 2019.


The finance ministry did not immediately respond to requests for comment.


Direct taxes typically account for about 80% of the government’s projections for annual revenue, and the shortfall may leave the government needing to boost borrowing to meet expenditure commitments.


The tax officials also say that a surprise cut in the headline corporate tax rate last year aimed at wooing manufacturers and boosting investment in Asia’s third-biggest economy is another reason behind the sluggish tax collections.

“We’ll be very happy if we can even break even with what we collected last year,” said another senior tax official in the financial capital, Mumbai, the biggest tax generator, accounting for about a third of revenues from direct taxes. “But given the state of the economy, I’m not too hopeful.”

The concerns are exacerbated by a gaping shortfall in the goods and services tax (GST) that is expected to further hurt total collections.

The total tax collection shortfall for the current fiscal year could be about 3 trillion rupees – the highest shortfall ever recorded.

“With revenue sources stretched, we’re not assuming any rise in the capex bill in FY21,” Pranjul Bhandari, chief economist at HSBC in India, said in a note, adding she expects the government to resort to higher borrowing from the market.

The government is likely to keep the fiscal deficit under 3.8% of gross domestic product, sources told Reuters earlier this month, while letting it slip from its earlier set target of 3.3% for the year.

Tax officials have been stuck between the increasing number of complaints of harassment from Indian businesses, dubbed “tax terrorism” by Indian media, and the government’s push to meet the target.

The government asked its officials at a meeting on Dec. 20 to identify and initiate stern action against wilful tax evaders, sources said.

“The message from the top is very clear – go all out and collect,” said a senior tax official in the eastern city of Kolkata.